2019 Offseason Questions: Who Is The Third-Greatest QB In Steelers History?

The Pittsburgh Steelers well underway with the offseason workouts at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex, also referred to as the South Side Facility. We are already into the heart of the offseason, where hope springs eternal following a few months of pretty significant changes, in terms of both departures and arrivals.

How are the rookies performing? What about the players that the team signed in free agency? Who is missing time with injuries, and when are they going to be back? What are the coaches saying about what they are going to do this season that might be different from how it was a year ago?

These are the sorts of questions among many others that we have been exploring on a daily basis and will continue to do so. Football has become a year-round pastime and there is always a question to be asked, though there is rarely a concrete answer, as I’ve learned in my years of doing this.

Question: Who is the third-greatest quarterback in Steelers history?

Following a recent article that attempted to rank the 25 greatest quarterbacks in the history of the NFL—in which Terry Bradshaw ranked 17th and Ben Roethlisberger ranked 19th—it got me to thinking about the rest of the Steelers’ history.

Bradshaw and Roethlisberger are pretty objectively the two greatest quarterbacks they’ve ever had (obviously, I’m not going to include somebody like Johnny Unitas in this discussion). They are the only ones who have really set meaningful records and helped bring championships to the city. And you can just see it on the field. Whichever order you would choose to place them in, I don’t think anybody would put either outside of the top two.

But who would be the third-best quarterback in team history after them? Kordell Stewart ranks third in franchise history in passing yards, as well as touchdowns, although he threw more interceptions. Neil O’Donnell, the only other quarterback to get them to a Super Bowl, is fourth in passing yards and just two touchdowns behind Stewart, with far fewer interceptions.

Then there’s Bobby Layne, who will probably be the most popular answer to this question. A Hall of Famer who had most of his success with the Detroit Lions, he wrapped up his career with about five years in Pittsburgh in the late 50s and early 60s and even managed a few winning seasons for the otherwise basement-dwelling franchise.

Of course, the one true, objective answer is Landry Jones, and the only reason that people don’t recognize his brilliance is because the team held him back in order to assuage Roethlisberger’s ego. Jones is the unrecognized genius of the past decade in the NFL, and it’s a shame how he’s been treated.

To Top