He wasn’t the first father to raise multiple Super Bowl champions. Nor was he the first to raise multiple Super Bowl champions himself. He’s not even the most famous father of multiple Super Bowl winners. But he is the first two do so as a former Super Bowl champion himself—and they all played the same position.
Archie Manning may have raised Peyton Manning and Eli Manning to become multiple-time winners, but he never won the game himself. Former Pittsburgh Steelers punter Craig Colquitt, however, can pair his rings up against those of his sons. Britton Colquitt won Super Bowl 50—with Peyton—with the Denver Broncos a few years ago. This past season, Dustin Colquitt claimed the most recent title with the Kansas City Chiefs.
According to NFL Research, this is the first and only instance of somebody winning a Super Bowl title and then having two sons also win a title. And of course all of them just so happen to be punters. All of them, at least, were good, relative to their time period.
Former @Steelers punter Craig Colquitt (SB XIII & XIV champion) became the 1st Super Bowl champion to also have 2 sons each win at least one Super Bowl as a player:
Former Chiefs punter Dustin Colquitt (SB LIV champion) & Vikings punter Britton Colquitt (SB 50 champion w/ DEN)
— NFL Research (@NFLResearch) June 22, 2020
Craig Colquitt was a rookie third-round pick for the Steelers in 1978. He punted in all 16 games in both of his first two seasons as the team claimed its third and fourth titles. Not a bad way to start off your career. In all, he would play six seasons in Pittsburgh, then one more with the Indianapolis Colts, before his career was over. He finished with an average of 41.3 yards per punt.
Britton Colquitt entered the league in 2010. He spent his first six seasons in Denver, but also had a three-year stint with the Cleveland Browns, and is currently with the Minnesota Vikings. He punted an astonishing 101 times for nearly 5000 yards in 2011. In the Super Bowl season of 2015, he averaged 43.6 yards per punt.
Dustin Colquitt is the older brother, and has been the Chiefs’ punter since 2005. He is among the oldest players in the NFL, now 38, and has been to the Pro Bowl multiple times. He has a 44.8-yard average for his career, and last season averaged 44.3 yards per punt.
Britton Colquitt currently has the 14th-best career average in NFL history, while Dustin owns the 25th-best career average. Craig ranks tied for 117, but relative for his time period is pretty competitive. The vast majority of the punters toward the top of the list began their career in the 2000s or later.
I’m not sure how often a pair of brothers wins the Super Bowl at the same time, but Jason and Devin McCourty were the latest to do it with the New England Patriots in 2018. The Steelers have a number of brothers on their current roster—even a pair of brothers together—but none of them have a ring.